MANAGEMENT ETHICS, MGTC59S

SPRING, 2001, THURSDAYS 3-5


Description I Course Materials I Evaluation I Case Presentation I
Class Participation
I Schedule


DESCRIPTION:

Increasingly, the marketplace has come to reward -- and government regulators have come to demand -- a sophisticated managerial approach to the ethical problems that arise in all areas of management practice. The purpose of this course is to provide students with a set of skills helpful in dealing with the ethical problems contemporary managers face.

The analytical and case material we discuss should enable you to formulate well-reasoned, theoretically and empirically-based viewpoints on difficult and controversial managerial issues. There will, for the most part, be no right or wrong answers to the questions raised in this course. There will, however, be such things as "good" or "bad" answers," depending on the extent to which they are based on a thorough understanding of theories and concepts, well-constructed reasoning, and accurate information.

Return to top of page

 

COURSE MATERIALS:

Business Ethics in Canada (3rd edition), edited by Deborah C. Poff and Wilfrid J. Waluchow,

Management Ethics (MGT C59S) Reading Packet

Return to top of page


EVALUATION:

Case Presentations 15%
Class Participation 15%
Mid-term exam 30%
Final exam 40%

Return to top of page

 

CASE PRESENTATION:

The class will have the opportunity to divide itself into eight groups, each of which will be responsible for "kicking off" one of the case discussions beginning January 20. Each group will have the opportunity to express its preference(s) as to which case to present. Needless to say, though, I reserve the right to assign groups cases they may not have chosen in order to ensure that all sessions have presentations, but I will do my best to honour group preferences.

Presenters should summarize the facts of the case, and then analyze those issues raised which are of interest from a broad managerial-ethics perspective. Presentations can, in whole or in part, take the form of role-playing and dialogue as well as a more straightforward discussion of the issues. They should be around 10 to 15 minutes in length. I am available and more than happy to talk, in detail, with each group as it plans its presentation.

Return to top of page

 

CLASS PARTICIPATION:

For this course to work, students must participate in class discussion. I want to point out, though, that the purpose of a class discussion is to advance as a group toward insight and understanding. Class discussion, in other words, is a cooperative, not a competitive exercise. You will thus be assessed on how well your remarks show that you are listening and responding to what others are saying, not on how articulate and eloquent you are. If you have steadily contributed to the progress of conversation over the term -- even if you have uttered no brilliant insights -- you will do well in your class-participation grade. Of course, I am not for a moment suggesting that brilliant insights are unwelcome in class; they are very welcome. But they are not expected or required. Class discussion is a group endeavour, and you will be marked on your display of those qualities that conduce to collective learning.

Return to top of page

 

SCHEDULE:

January 11

Introduction

Andrew Stark, "What's the Matter with Business Ethics?" (Packet, pp. i- viii)

January 18

Ethical Theory in Business

Text: Poff and Waluchow p. 1 to 20 (stop at "Pluralism -- W.D. Ross"); pp. 35-36 ("Concluding Thoughts")

Case: CBS v. Andy Rooney (Packet, pp. 1-2)

January 25

The Problem of Dirty Hands

Text: Poff and Waluchow pp. 39-53; 54-69

Case: Viking Air Compressor, Inc. (Packet, pp. 3-7)

February 1 The Problem of Many Hands

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 196-217

Case: Roger Boisjoly and the Challenger Disaster (Poff and Waluchow, pp. 229-248)

February 8 Health and Safety in the Workplace

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 164-181

Case: American Cyanamid Company (Packet, pp. 8-16) or Pinto Fires (Packet, pp. 17-19)

February 15 MID-TERM
Februrary 22 READING WEEK
March 1 Employment Equity

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 252-287

Cases: "Sing's Chinese Restaurant"; "Comparable Worth in the Female Section" (Packet, pp. 19a-19b)

March 8 Environmental Effects of Business Activities

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 319-342

Case: Mercury in the Environment (Poff and Waluchow, pp. 373-384)

March 15 Ethical Issues in International Business

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 406-428; Packet 19c-w

Cases: "A South African Investment;" "Two Cases of Questionable Payments" (Packet, pp. 20-33)

March 22 Ethical Issues in Advertising

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 440-461

Cases: "Seven Marketing Pitches," "Listerine and Corrective Advertising, " "Advertising Headaches" (Packet, pp. 34-36)

March 29 Lying and Deception in Business

Text: Poff and Waluchow, pp. 490-509

Cases: "Honesty and Deception in Business: Fudging the Travel Claim" (Packet 36a-36b) and "The Good Business Reference" (Packet, p. 37).

April 5 Ethical Issues of Insider Trading and Conclusion

Text: Poff and Waluchow, 510-514

 

Return to top of page

Return to Index page